Satisfy Your Pizza Craving with this Heart Healthy Pizza

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy

Watch the recipe

YouTube ↗

I was up for a challenge and went for it: Can I really make a healthy pizza? Yes, you see those recipes for makeshift pizzas all over the Internet for everyone who’s looking to go on some sort of diet. However, I wanted not only to make a healthy pizza, but to make one that is true to my style of cooking and is still tasty.

I believe with this Healthy Pizza that it’s mission accomplished! I’m still using my favourite pizza crust and toppings with only a few modifications (and believe it or not - additions!) to make this pizza delicious and great for your health. If you want to make a lifestyle change but don’t want to cut pizza out of your life, then there is no reason to do so! Depending on your situation, you can easily incorporate this Heart Healthy Pizza any time you would like! I mention in my free motivational guide to explore your potential in the kitchen, Make Cooking Fun!!, that being realistic with your goals is key. While I am referring mostly to cooking, this can also mean to cravings. Cutting things out of your diet entirely is a recipe for disaster, but allowing yourself flexibility to enjoy tasty foods will help tremendously. When you see that you have the power to cook delicious food that is actually nutritious, you’ll be amazed!

Definitely be sure to love your heart with this healthy pizza recipe as part of your Live to Cook one-month challenge. You can get started for free by signing up to my email newsletter today, and you’ll receive all of my latest recipes right to your inbox!

For a step-by-step visual of how to make the pizza dough, topping and broiling the pizza, be sure to watch the video! If you’re not already, be sure to subscribe to my YouTube channel, and press the bell button to be notified when all of my video recipes are live! Let’s get cooking!

Can a Pizza Really Be Healthy?

Depending on where you’re from in the world, you know pizza as an epic dinner. It’s the preferred choice for family gatherings and parties. You may think that there’s no way a pizza can be healthy. Well, let’s see what we can do to modify that!

After wanting to all my life, I finally went to Italy, and I observed how the pizzas were prepared there. The crusts are definitely on the thinner side, and toppings aren’t overloaded, especially the cheese. While it’s not the crazy social media cheese pulls or a loaded stuffed crust pizza, I really enjoyed the light pizzas so I could taste all the flavours!

• Homemade crust: A homemade pizza is truly the language of love, in my opinion. Using your own crust really makes a difference! You have the choice of the type of flour you’re using and the thickness of the crust, plus you’ve got no preservatives. Now, you may be asking: whole wheat or white flour? Everyone praises whole wheat to be the ultimate nutritional choice, but if you’ve got lots of veggies on top, then the fibre you wouldn’t get from the whole wheat crust is negligible. Plus, if you want to stick to your healthy lifestyle, then you have to enjoy it! If you prefer white flour, then go ahead and do that. What will actually really help our health in this homemade crust in particular is the fermentation, coming from the “poolish.” This step is preliminary to making the dough.
• Size: The smaller the portion the less calories you will eat! If you want the satisfaction of eating an entire pizza, simply use less dough to make it. This pizza is smaller than the usual pizzas I make. Of course, just to be clear, depending on what your body needs and your current health status, I’m not giving a blanket statement to eat the whole pizza.
• Homemade sauce: To be fair I always make my own pizza sauce, and that’s the way to go! You avoid preservatives, artificial colour dyes, and who knows what else. Plus, it’s easy and tasty!
• Moderate amount of cheese: Yes, cheese pulls are fun, but even part-skim mozzarella cheese is high in calories and saturated fat, and each little bit will add up quickly.
• Olive oil: Although calorie-dense, olive oil is excellent for your heart health. This reduces bad cholesterol and raises the good one. We’ll be brushing some olive oil on the crust and drizzling it over the pizza.

Other Topping Ideas

• Vegetables: You could also do cherry tomatoes, other pepper colours, mushrooms, or zucchini.
• Greens: Spinach or kale.
• Protein: For vegetarians, you can do tofu. For meat-eaters, another lean protein is extra lean ground beef, turkey breast, or pork tenderloin. For pescatarians, shrimp is a lean protein choice!

Tools Needed to Make Heart Healthy Pizza

• Baking steel and/or baking stone
• KitchenAid
• Wooden pizza peeland ametal peel
• Bench scraper
• Pizza wheel cutter
• Mixing bowl
• Whisk
• Garlic press
• Cutting board
• Basting brush
• Paring knife
• Ramekins

Ingredients for a Heart Healthy Pizza

Scroll to the bottom of this post or press the “Jump to Recipe” button for FULL PRINTABLE RECIPE CARD that has all ingredients and their quantities, plus you can save the recipe for later. You’ll also be able to scale the recipe based on how many pizzas you’re looking to make so that you have the right amount of toppings!

For the Pizza Dough

• 00 flour or bread flour: The preferred choice is 00 flour, but if for whatever reason you can’t find it, then feel free to substitute with bread flour.
• Instant Yeast
• Salt
• Lukewarm water (60-70F) + ~200 g/mL lukewarm water (60-70F)
• Extra virgin olive oil

For the Sauce

• Extra virgin olive oil
• Passata or tomato puree
• Garlic cloves: Minced
• Dried oregano
• Tomato paste
• Chilli flakes
• Salt to taste

For the Healthy Pizza

• Mozzarella cheese: Part-skimmed mozzarella is key here so that you get the flavour of a classic pizza but without overdoing the greasiness.
• Chicken: We’ll first pan-fry our chicken breast and then we’ll cut this into small pieces to add over the pizza.
• Vegetables: Tomatoes, green peppers, and onions.
• Arugula: Some greens to be added at the end so that you keep the crunch!
• Olive oil & minced garlic: To brush on the crust when the pizzas have finished baking.
• 00 flour or bread flour: As required for dusting.

How to Make Heart-Healthy Pizza

For the Poolish

Add the yeast and water to a bowl and whisk well until the yeast is dissolved and you see bubbles at the top. If you don't see bubbles, the yeast is dead and you need to restart with a fresh batch of yeast.

Add flour and mix well with a spatula and scrape down the sides of the bowl.

Cover with a plastic wrap and set in a warm, draft free place for 18 hours. If you will not be using the poolish immediately after, store in the fridge. Before using, allow the chill to come off by setting the poolish on the countertop for at least 30 mins.

For the Pizza Dough

Add yeast and 70 g of lukewarm water to a bowl and whisk until water is bubbly. Mix until you see no granules of yeast floating on the water. If the yeast doesn't dissolve, the yeast is likely dead and you will have to start over with fresh yeast.

Add flour to the bowl of your kitchen aid mixer and add all of the yeast-water mixture. Then, slowly add most of the cold water while continuing to knead with the dough hook. Add the remaining cold water back in the bowl of yeast water and swirl and add to the dough.

Knead until the dough comes together and there is no dry bits of flour. Stop the mixer and add the poolish, continue to knead until you have a soft, pliable dough which is not sticky to touch. Add more flour/water as required to reach this consistency.

Stop the mixer and add the salt. Knead on low speed for 1 minute.

Stop the mixer, add the olive oil and knead on low speed for 1 minute. After 1 minute, remove the dough from the dough hook, place in the bowl of the mixer and knead for 30 seconds to a minute.

Then, transfer the dough to your countertop and continue kneading, stretch and fold the dough for 1-2 minutes.

Form the dough into a ball and set aside on the countertop/bowl. Cover with a damp kitchen towel and let rest for 20 minutes.

Then, portion the dough into 3 equal parts and for each portion fold the dough onto itself to create a tight surface tension as you seal/pinch the folds. Be careful not to de-gas the dough too much. The portions should resemble a ball of fresh mozzarella. This is a great time to freeze any dough you are not planning to use right away.

Transfer the dough portions to a baking sheet or plate and cover with 2 layers of plastic wrap. Let the dough rise for at least 24-72 hours in the refrigerator.

For the Sauce

In a bowl, combine all the ingredients for the sauce, mash the tomatoes and mix well. Adjust with salt for seasoning.

For the Toppings

Place one baking steel/stone on the second highest rack of the oven and another one at the bottom most rack. Preheat oven at 500 F for 1 hour. Remove the pizza dough and sauce out to come up to temperature while the oven preheats.

Dust your countertop with flour and starting with one portion of dough at a time, add the dough ball over the dusting mixture. Starting from the centre of the dough, press down on the dough and create a rim around the side.

Continue pressing down the centre to stretch the dough. Then, hold the dough from the rim and rotate to let gravity stretch if further. You can also you use knuckles to stretch the dough, until the diameter is about 10 inches.

To Cook the Pizzas

Set oven to Broil mode, let top steel/stone heat for 8-10 minutes.

Dust a wooden pizza peel with flour and place the stretched dough on the peel.

Add 1/3rd of the tomato sauce and spread until the edge of the pizza. Add the mozzarella and spread evenly.

Add the chicken, onions, peppers, tomatoes, and olive oil. Spread evenly over the pizza.

In a swift push and pull motion, place the pizza on the top baking steel/stone.

Bake for 1 1/2 - 2 minutes or until the crust has some char or brown spots and the cheese has molten.

Then transfer the pizza to the bottom steel/stone to finish off the crust of the pizza, about 30 seconds to 1 minute.

Remove the pizza from the oven and top with garlic oil. Slice the pizza and then top with arugula.

Serve hot and enjoy!

Tips for a Tasty and Nutritious Pizza

• If the yeast doesn’t dissolve after mixing, the yeast is likely dead. As a result, it’s best to start over.
• Avoid degassing the dough too much as you are folding the individual portions onto itself. If you over-work the dough, it will start to resist as you start to stretch the dough for the pizza.
• To continue on your pizza-making journey after this recipe, I highly recommend you invest in a baking steel and/or baking stone. They are cheap, and an essential tool for pizza makers.
• You want to preheat your oven to its highest temperature for at least one hour before baking the pizza. This will mean that your baking steel and/or baking stone is hot and ready for pizza, giving you the crispiest crust.
• Use a pair of baking steels/stones if possible, setting up one of them towards the top rack of the oven and the second one at the bottom.
• Turn the oven to the “Broil” mode 10 minutes prior to cooking the pizzas (I do this right before topping the pizza) to make the top steel/stone scorching hot. This will help rapidly cook the crispy crust.
• Finish the crust by transferring the pizza to the bottom stone/steel.
• Keep the arugula chilled in the fridge until ready to serve to keep it nice and crisp.