Ninja review
Ninja Creami Swirl Review: A Year In, 6 Settings, 1 Exploded Pint
Disclosure: I bought this with my own money. No brand involvement. Shop links may earn a small commission at no cost to you.
I bought the Ninja Swirl in October 2025 for soft serve, and I've made it almost every day since. Here's what a year and six settings taught me, the pint that exploded, and whether I'd buy it again.
The verdict
Yes, I'd buy it again, because I make soft serve almost every day and this is the only Creami that does it. If you don't need soft serve, another Creami model is fine. Just know it's a plan-ahead machine: every pint needs a day in the freezer.
What's good
- The soft serve. The best chocolate soft serve I've had came out of this machine
- My McFlurry recipe came out much better as soft serve than it ever did on my old Creami
- Soft serve isn't just one setting. Frozen custard, frozen yogurt, lite ice cream and regular ice cream all came out of the dispenser
- One pint lasts. Level it, freeze it, re-spin it later, or turn the leftovers into a milkshake
What's not
- Everything needs 24 hours in the freezer. No ice cream on a whim
- It's loud. Quieter than my old Creami, but not by much
- Lots of small parts and rubber rings to clean
- The pints are expensive, your old Creami pints won't do soft serve, and a cheap third-party pint exploded on us
Best for
- Anyone who loves soft serve and is happy to plan a day ahead
- People who'll prep a few pints at a time
Not for
- Anyone who wants ice cream tonight
- Anyone who doesn't need soft serve. Another Creami model will do the job
The receipt
What it cost me
- Paid
- $338.97
- Bought
- October 10, 2025
- From
- Amazon
- Since then
- $107.00
- All in
- $445.97
- Extra pints, first 4 pack, $40.00, October 11, 2025. Bought right away because I knew I'd need more than one pint
- Spare dispenser lid, $27.00, March 31, 2026. The original dispenser lid broke Check the price
- Extra pints, second 4 pack, $40.00, September 17, 2026. One of the first pints exploded Check the price
The facts
Specs that matter
- Model
- NC701C
- What makes it different
- A dispensing lid and lever for soft serve. Every other Creami only scoops
- Programs
- 7 scoop and 6 soft serve, per the Ninja Swirl recipe book
- Pints
- Each Swirl pint has a nozzle built into the bottom
- Drip tray
- A slide-out tray under the dispenser
- Noise
- 83 to 85 dB on a spin, measured on my phone
- Owned since
- 10 October 2025, in use since November 2025
How I tested it
The tests
1.Cookies and cream frozen custard, from the book
PassedWhat I did: The book's frozen custard: egg yolks, sugar, cream and milk cooked on the stove and stirred so the eggs don't curdle, with crushed cookies cooked in. Frozen 24 hours. Soft serve, then frozen custard.
What happened: Great soft serve, straight from the dispenser.

2.Chocolate frozen custard, my own recipe
PassedWhat I did: The same custard idea, my own chocolate version. Frozen 24 hours. Soft serve, then frozen custard.
What happened: The best chocolate soft serve I've had.

3.Vanilla, the first time I used the scoop setting
PassedWhat I did: The book's vanilla: cream cheese, sugar, vanilla, cream and milk. No stove. Frozen 24 hours. Scoop, then ice cream.
What happened: Absolutely delicious. I'm kicking myself for waiting nine months to try it.

4.Noise, against my old Creami
MixedWhat I did: A decibel app on my phone, next to each machine during a spin.
What happened: 83 to 85 dB on the Swirl, 87 to 89 on my old Creami. Quieter on paper, but you won't hear the difference.

5.Re-freezing a half-eaten pint
PassedWhat I did: Levelled what was left in the pint, lid on, back in the freezer, then re-spun it before serving.
What happened: It comes back good. Ninja says it's best within two weeks.
6.Chocolate hazelnut frozen yogurt, from the book
MixedWhat I did: Full-fat plain yogurt, chocolate hazelnut spread, cocoa and vanilla. Frozen 24 hours. Soft serve, then frozen yogurt.
What happened: It was all right. Nothing amazing. It tastes like chocolate frozen yogurt, not ice cream.

7.Lite coffee ice cream, made with dairy
PassedWhat I did: The book's lite coffee chip, made with heavy cream and whole milk instead of the dairy-free ingredients, stevia instead of monkfruit, and no chips. Frozen 24 hours. Soft serve, then lite ice cream.
What happened: My mom and I finished the whole pint in one sitting.

8.My frozen hot chocolate McFlurry as soft serve
PassedWhat I did: My own recipe, a plain ice cream base with no eggs. Soft serve, then ice cream. On my old Creami the same base needed ice cream, a re-spin and a mix-in.
What happened: Much better than on my old Creami. A really nice soft serve, and my favourite of everything I made.

9.Milkshake from leftover frozen yogurt
PassedWhat I did: About half a pint of leftover frozen yogurt spun on scoop, then about half a cup of milk added. Scoop, then milkshake.
What happened: Really good. Thick and ice-creamy, not a blended mess, and it took almost no extra work.

10.A third-party pint from Amazon on the dispenser
FailedWhat I did: My wife's protein ice cream on the Creamifit setting, in a cheaper pint from Amazon, sent straight to the soft serve dispenser before it had spun smooth.
What happened: The base was still too frozen and the pint exploded under the pressure.

Honest use
How I actually use it
November 2025 to August 2026
daily
- Soft serve on the frozen custard setting
- Cookies and cream custard
- Chocolate custard
Since August 2026
daily
- Soft serve on frozen custard, frozen yogurt, lite ice cream and ice cream
- Scoop ice cream
- Milkshakes from leftover pints
- My wife's protein ice cream on Creamifit
I bought the Ninja Swirl in October 2025 for one reason: soft serve. It's the only Creami that makes it, and both my wife and I have a strong preference to soft serve ice cream instead of hard ice cream. I started using it a month later, once my old Creami I was waiting for my old Creami model to be sold. Ever since then, soft serve has been made in it twice a day almost every single day by my wife. Of course I played around with it here and there, too!
For nine months I only ever pressed two buttons, which were used for my first Ninja Creami Swirl Review video on YouTube. I always knew it was a great machine, and after seeing so many positive comments wanting more demos on the machine, and my curiosity getting the better of me, I finally explored more! It also helped having my mom staying over with me who really wanted to try all the fun ice creams. Six settings later, here's what a year with this machine looks like, including the McFlurry that beat my old Creami and the third-party pint that exploded all over our kitchen.
Why I bought the Ninja Creami Swirl
I bought this ice cream maker for soft serve, and that's still the best reason to buy it. The Swirl is the only Creami that comes with the dispensing lid and the lever. Everything else it does, the older Creamis do too. Soft serve is made pretty much every day (protein-style) here, so it’s definitely a soft serve lover’s choice.
Be Sure to Plan Your Ice Cream Nights in Advance!
This isn't a machine you use because you suddenly got an ice cream craving. Ninja officially states to freeze every pint for 24 hours, and they do mean it! If you want soft serve on a Saturday, you need to plan accordingly to make the base on Friday. In all of my demos, the pints have been frozen for 24 hours or more. My wife has made creamis with less freeze time than this, but I’m not going to recommend it for the machine to work its best!
The upside is that a pint isn't one dessert. Scoop what you want, level the rest back out, put the lid on and put it back in the freezer. It keeps for about two weeks. Re-spin it when you take it back out. Or turn what's left into a milkshake: I made one from half a pint of leftover frozen yogurt, and I really enjoyed it! It made me realize how much I love milkshakes, but I don’t have them very often! I need to make some more milkshakes with this machine, that’s for sure! By the way, if you do have ice cream, whether store-bought or made with your Ninja Creami, then that setting is the one exception that you can make instantly.
You don't NEED a custard base for soft serve
When I first got this ice cream maker, I made custard bases for my soft serve, with egg yolks cooked on the stove. That's what the advanced recipes in the book use, and they're so good!
But it isn't the only way, and as the book describes, the custard versions are “advanced.” It was my ambition that made me want to start the most elaborate soft serves right off the bat! My frozen hot chocolate McFlurry is a plain ice cream base, no eggs, and on the soft serve setting with the ice cream program it came out better than it ever did on my old Creami. The frozen yogurt and the lite coffee ice cream came out of the dispenser too.
The Setting Ignored for 9 Months
I'd never pressed the scoop button. When I finally did, the vanilla was absolutely delicious, and it was the easiest base I'd made, since no stove was required!
Then I tried four more settings: milkshake, lite ice cream, frozen yogurt, and soft serve ice cream. The lite coffee ice cream that I adapted my way from the book was the surprise. My mom and I finished the whole pint in one sitting! To be fair, we did substitute the plant-based milk with milk and we used heavy cream. Lite ice cream means to use a sugar substitute, as the base will freeze differently when using sugar substitutes. I used stevia instead of the monkfruit the book suggested, since we always have stevia on hand.
The settings I still haven’t used are sorbet, fruit whip, gelato, and creamifit, though my wife uses creamifit for her protein ice creams. I’m open to trying all of these except sorbet, since I personally don’t like sorbet!
How Loud Is the Ninja Creami Swirl?
I’m not going to lie, the sound really bothers me! Be prepared for it to be LOUD! I run away to the bedroom to drown out the sound when the machine runs. The Swirl runs at 83 to 85 decibels on a spin. My old Creami ran at 87 to 89. It's quieter on paper, but your ears won't notice. You're not having a conversation over it.
How to Clean the Ninja Creami Swirl
Every so often it needs a proper clean. There are a lot of rubber rings and plastic parts that food gets stuck in, and the gear that spins the blade gets dirty over time, as does the spot where the soft serve attachment clicks in. A toothbrush and a damp microfiber cloth do the job.
The thing it took us ages to learn: the little blue silicone ring on the soft serve attachment clicks off. Take it off when you clean it.
The Pint that Exploded
Extra pints are expensive, so it's tempting to buy cheaper ones. Unfortunately, you also can’t use the pints from the previous Ninja Creami model if you have them because Swirl pints have the nozzle built into the bottom to dispense the soft serve.
On 19 October, my wife was making her protein ice cream on the Creamifit setting in a cheaper pint from Amazon. The base was still too frozen and hadn't spun smooth, and she went straight to the soft serve dispenser. The pressure built up and the pint exploded everywhere.
Re-spin before you dispense
If a base looks crumbly or hard, re-spin it before you pull the lever. The Ninja book says the same. And think hard before you put a cheap pint under that kind of pressure.
Would I buy it again?
Yes, as a soft serve lover, this ice cream maker is definitely worth it! This machine is put to use almost every day, and that's what this machine has done for me most of the time, so it's been really valuable. It costs you a day of planning every time, and a cheap pint cost some wasted ice cream and a hefty cleanup!
If you don't need soft serve, you don't need the Swirl. For basic ice cream, the original Ninja Creami is excellent! I used the original Ninja Creami for nearly two years before the upgrade, and it was also used at least twice a day every day. If you want larger pints and more settings, then try the Ninja Creami Deluxe.
If you get one, these are the extra pints I bought, and this is the spare dispenser lid I bought.
Still true?
The long-term log
Bought for $338.97 on Amazon, with my own money. I started using it about a month later, once my old Creami was sold, and I've made soft serve almost every day since.
Posted a Short of the cookies and cream frozen custard from the book.
The dispenser lid broke, so I bought a spare.
Measured the noise: 83 to 85 dB on the Swirl, against 87 to 89 on my old Creami.
Nine months in, the first review. I finally used the scoop setting, and the vanilla was great.
A third-party pint from Amazon exploded on the soft serve dispenser.
This review. Four new settings: frozen yogurt, lite ice cream and my McFlurry as soft serve, plus a milkshake.
Or instead
Alternatives I'd consider
The original Ninja Creami
owned itPick it when: You don't need soft serve. It does everything the Swirl does except soft serve, and it's a little louder. I sold mine when the Swirl came in.
You asked
Questions people ask
Can I use my old Ninja Creami pints in the Swirl?
Not for soft serve. Swirl pints have a nozzle built into the bottom, and that's where the soft serve comes out.
How loud is the Ninja Swirl?
I measured 83 to 85 decibels on a spin. My old Creami was 87 to 89. Quieter, but not by enough to notice.
Do I have to eat the whole pint at once?
No. Level it out, lid on, back in the freezer. Ninja says it's best within two weeks. Re-spin it before you serve it. Or turn the rest into a milkshake.
Do I really have to freeze it for 24 hours?
Yes. That's what Ninja says, and it's why this is a plan-ahead machine.
Do I need a custard base for soft serve?
No. The book's advanced soft serve recipes use custard, but my McFlurry is a plain ice cream base and it made great soft serve. Frozen yogurt and a lite ice cream came out of the dispenser too.
Is the Swirl worth it over a regular Creami?
Only if you want soft serve. That's the one thing it does that the others don't. I make soft serve almost every day, so for me it is.
Are cheap third-party pints safe to use?
One exploded on us when the base was too frozen and went straight to the dispenser. Re-spin anything crumbly or hard before you dispense, and be careful with cheap pints.
See it in action
Recipes I use it for

Free guide
7 Quick Dinners
Easy weeknight dinners you'll make on repeat.
40,000 home cooks a month cook from this site. Get one tested recipe a week from it, plus the weeknight tip that makes it work.

Comments
No comments yet — be the first to share your thoughts!
Leave a comment
Be the first to comment.